Topic: Mentoring Programs (Child & Adolescent)

Scientific Ratings in this topic:

1 - Well-Supported by Research Evidence

2 - Supported by Research Evidence

3 - Promising Research Evidence

4 - Evidence Fails to Demonstrate Effect

5 - Concerning Practice

NR - Not able to be Rated

Learn more about the scale

Definition for Mentoring Programs (Child & Adolescent):

Mentoring Programs (Child & Adolescent) are defined by the CEBC as programs in which there is a structured relationship between a child or adolescent involved in the child welfare system and an older individual (the mentor), with the goal of developing the competence and potential of the child or adolescent (the mentee). Children placed in foster, kinship, and congregate care may experience multiple placement changes and/or reunification, leading to instability in home, neighborhood, school, and community environments. A mentor may serve as a stable adult in a young person's life throughout these transitions.

  • Target population: Children and adolescents involved in the child welfare system, especially those in out-of-home care
  • Services/types that fit: Programs in which there is a structured relationship between a child/youth and an older individual, with the goal of developing the competence and potential of the mentee
  • Delivered by: Trained adult mentors and the agency staff that supervise them (child welfare staff, mental health professionals, or trained paraprofessionals)
  • In order to be included: Mentoring services must be a primary mechanism for the program
  • In order to be rated: There must be research evidence (as specified by the Scientific Rating Scale) that examines outcomes for the youth, such as changes in child welfare outcomes (e.g., reduced out-of-home placement, placement changes, etc.) or changes in youth behavior, symptom levels, and/or functioning.
Downloadable Topic Area Summary

Programs in this Topic Area

The programs listed below have been reviewed by the CEBC and, if appropriate, been rated using the Scientific Rating Scale.

Two Programs with a Scientific Rating of 1 - Well-Supported by Research Evidence:

  • Fostering Healthy Futures - Preteen (FHF-P)
    Preadolescent children (ages 9-11) who have current or previous child welfare involvement due to one or more adverse childhood experiences (...
  • My Life
    Youth and young adults, ages 15-19, in foster care who are able to go into the community with their program ...

One Program with a Scientific Rating of 2 - Supported by Research Evidence:

  • Better Futures
    Youth and young adults in foster care, including youth with disabilities and/or mental health conditions, who are: 1) in their ...

Five Programs with a Scientific Rating of 3 - Promising Research Evidence:

  • Across Ages – non-responder
    Youth ages 9 to 13 who are at a high-risk for substance abuse
  • Big Brothers Big Sisters of America (BBBSA)
    Youth aged 5-18 seeking additional support from a caring adult who guides them through goal-setting activities and relationship building skills ...
  • Friends for Youth 1 to 1 Mentoring
    [Friends for Youth Mentoring Services]
    Youth ages 8-17 (referred by teachers, counselors, probation officers, county mental health, child protective/welfare services, or other youth-serving professionals) ...
  • Friends of the Children (FOTC)
    Children ages 4-6 years who are at serious risk of entering or reentering foster care, and/or who are already ...
  • Transition to Independence Process (TIP) Model
    Youth and young adults (14-29 years old) with, or at risk of, emotional/behavioral difficulties (EBD) [e.g., severe mental ...

Two Programs with a Scientific Rating of NR - Not able to be Rated:

  • BEST Kids
    Youth aged 6 to 21 years who are currently in or have been in the child welfare system
  • Silver Lining Mentoring (SLM)
    [Adoption and Foster Care Mentoring]
    Youth (ages 7+) with current or prior experience in foster care

Why was this topic chosen by the Advisory Committee?

The Mentoring Programs (Child & Adolescent) topic area is relevant to child welfare because mentoring programs can be a way for improving outcomes for youth in the child welfare system. Children in the foster care system often lack connections to adults who can provide support and guidance, and model how to successfully negotiate the many challenges in life. Too many foster children limit their own expectations for themselves since they lack the opportunities to see possibilities for their lives.

Danna Fabella, Director
Federal Linkages
Child & Family Policy Institute of California
Sacramento, CA

Topic Expert

The Mentoring Programs (Child & Adolescent) topic area was added in 2012. Heather Taussig, PhD, was the topic expert and was involved in identifying and rating any of the programs with an original load date in 2012 (as found on the bottom of the program's page on the CEBC) or others loaded earlier and added to this topic area when it launched. The topic area has grown over the years and any programs added since 2012 were identified by CEBC staff, the Scientific Panel, and/or the Advisory Committee. For these programs, Dr. Taussig was not involved in identifying or rating them.